This story is about Carol*, a grad student in California.
When I first met her, she told me she had a much younger sister, ten years younger to be exact. It's not the most usual but also not the most unusual. The story got fascinating, when Carol started telling me about her annual bills for medical freezing services that ran up to USD 2,000. This all might not make much sense right now, but let me start from the beginning.
Carol's father is an orthopedic surgeon, specializing on hip and knee surgeries and in his free time he collaborates with university students from Germany inventing medical devices. Carol's mother is a teacher.
After Carol was born, her parents wanted to have another child – but for some reason it didn't quite work. Years of hormone treatments followed and they finally were successful with in vitro.
In vitro fertilisation is a process where they take eggs and fertilize them in a test tube, hence the name. The scientists then look at how many eggs have been successfully inseminated and plant those back into the uterus.
Now, I'm sure you've heard of the octuplets and sextuplets in this world. Many of these have so many siblings because as Carol explains “No scientific decision is being made, like my dad did, but all eggs are put back into the uterus.”
In Carol's case, her father – the scientist – decided that they'd only put two out of the four successfully inseminated and healthily developing eggs into her mom's uterus. The remaining ones, they stuck into the freezer – a professional, medical freezer of course. At this point, Carol explains that “other couples get into ethical and religious arguments where they feel like are they are killing their children or playing God by selecting one egg over the other. My dad was just my dad, the scientist, and there was no issue with freezing the other ones.”
As the pregnancy develops, her mother experiences a miscarriage and only one child is born – exactly as the parents had hoped for.
Carol learns all this as a ten year-old, being the daughter of a scientist it doesn't strike her as very unusual.
The years go by, and as Carol and her sister grow up there is mentioning of the fertilized eggs that are still in the freezer. Her mother starts wondering what to do with them and being her philanthropic self, she entertains thoughts of giving them to couples who can't have children. The moment she voices her plans to her husband - Carol's father – he objects. He doesn't want his genetic material to end up with a family he doesn't know and have no connections with. He'd rather donate them to science. To this proposal, Carol's mom can't agree to. “Why should she let science do cruel experiments with my siblings?” Carol remarks. And so, the eggs stay in the freezer and Carol's parents keep paying the freezer bills.
So, how does Carol end up with the freezer bills?
Carol goes off to college and on one of her trips home, finds her parents putting together their will. Sitting down with to finalize the process, their lawyer asks them the following question: “Besides real estate, bank accounts, life insurance and other assets, are there any unusual assets?”
Her parents and Carol look at each other: “Uhm, the eggs in the freezer!”
Her parents can't agree on what to do, so a spontaneous decision is made: they sign them over to their daughter.
Here is Carol, 22 years old, a grad school student, having inherited her siblings-to-be who sit in a medical freezer because her parents can't agree what to do with them.
Maybe realizing the awkwardness, Carol's dad adds a new spin to this. In case his daughter doesn't meet Mr. Right in her fertile years, or in case she might have troubles getting pregnant, she could always give birth to what genetically are her sibling. Sounds all great to a scientist …
Here is Carol's take on her father's offer: “How am I going to convince my future husband to have children that technically are my siblings, and then give birth to them?”
In the end, her parents continue paying for the freezer bills and not much has changed. But Carol has come to the conclusion that she has helped her parents with the conundrum, and reassures herself that “the eggs are probably freezer burned by now, so that's that.”
Special thanks to Carol for sharing your family story with WellAroundTheWorld!
*as always, names are changed to protect patient privacy.